Dr. Isabella M. Laurent¹, Dr. Jonathan R. Meyer², Dr. Chiara B. Romano³, Dr. Erik L. Schneider4, Dr. Sofia K. Alvarez5
¹ Department of Cultural Studies, Sorbonne University, France
² Institute of Heritage and Museum Studies, University of Vienna, Austria
³ Department of Arts and Humanities, University of Florence, Italy
4 Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Copenhagen, Denmark
5 Department of Anthropology, University of Barcelona, Spain
Correspondence
Correspondence to: Dr. Isabella M. Laurent, Department of Cultural Studies, Sorbonne University, Paris, France.
Email: [email protected]
Abstract
Museums occupy a central position at the intersection of cultural heritage preservation and cultural industry development. This study explores the complex responsibilities of museums in maintaining equilibrium between safeguarding heritage and fostering cultural enterprises. By examining illustrative case studies, innovative practices, and emerging obstacles, the research highlights how museums respond to the dual mandate of conservation and commercialisation. The findings emphasise the critical need to sustain both heritage integrity and economic sustainability. Ultimately, this paper seeks to advance scholarly understanding of the strategies, opportunities, and challenges museums encounter while sustaining a mutually reinforcing relationship between cultural heritage and cultural industries.
Keywords: Heritage Conservation, Museum Management, Cultural Industries, Sustainable Development, Commercialisation of Culture.
© The Author(s) 2025. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License, which permits any non-commercial use, sharing, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if you modified the licensed material. You do not have permission under this licence to share adapted material derived from this article or parts of it. The images or other third-party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Introduction
The preservation of cultural heritage and the advancement of cultural industries represent two vital dimensions of contemporary society. Museums, as custodians of cultural artifacts and centers of knowledge dissemination, occupy a central position in balancing these seemingly contrasting objectives. The complex interaction between conserving cultural heritage and promoting cultural industry development has gained increasing importance in recent years [1].
This study investigates the multifaceted role museums play in navigating this delicate balance. Positioned between the responsibility of protecting the past and contributing to the present economy, museums face a critical challenge: how can they safeguard cultural heritage while also participating in commercially driven activities? In addressing this question, the research further examines innovative approaches museums adopt to reconcile preservation with commercialisation, highlighting strategies that may serve as effective responses to the tensions inherent in this dual mandate.
Cultural Heritage and Cultural Industry
In contemporary society, cultural heritage and cultural industries have emerged as essential social and economic assets, attracting significant scholarly and policy attention. The relationship between the two is evident, as cultural heritage provides a deep reservoir of inspiration, narratives, and content for cultural products and experiences. Preserving heritage is not only crucial for maintaining collective identity but also for fostering social cohesion and a shared sense of belonging. Heritage sites, artifacts, and traditions serve as tangible and intangible links to history, offering valuable insights into the evolution of cultures and societies. Safeguarding these resources ensures the protection of cultural diversity and supports the intergenerational transmission of knowledge, thereby reinforcing collective memory and understanding of the past.
At the same time, the cultural industry has seen remarkable expansion in response to the growing global demand for creative and cultural goods. Industries such as film, music, fashion, and design contribute substantially to economic development, innovation, and employment opportunities [2]. Nonetheless, the intersection of cultural heritage and cultural industry also raises challenges. The tension between commercial imperatives and the authenticity of cultural expression is a recurring concern. Achieving an appropriate balance between economic viability and the preservation of cultural integrity remains a pressing issue for stakeholders in both sectors.
Dual Missions of Museums
3.1. Safeguarding and Transmitting Cultural Heritage
Museums occupy a crucial role in the preservation and transmission of cultural heritage. As custodians of culture, they collect, conserve, and exhibit valuable artefacts, ensuring the continuity of human history, traditions, and legacies. These artefacts not only serve as tangible witnesses to the past but also function as educational resources for future generations. Through curated exhibitions, educational programming, and research initiatives, museums facilitate public engagement with cultural heritage, promoting a deeper understanding of historical contexts, cultural identity, and societal roots.
3.2. Promoting Cultural Industry Development
In addition to heritage preservation, museums play an active role in fostering the cultural industry. In today’s knowledge and creativity-driven economies, the cultural sector has become a key engine of economic growth and innovation. Museums act as strategic facilitators by leveraging cultural resources to attract visitors, inspire creativity, and generate cultural products. Through exhibitions, events, and collaborative initiatives, museums provide rich content and resources that feed into the broader cultural industry, stimulating market activity and creative enterprise [3]. By simultaneously safeguarding cultural heritage and supporting cultural industry development, museums fulfill a dual mission that enhances both societal and economic value. However, balancing these objectives is inherently complex. The following section explores the challenges inherent in this dual role and examines potential strategies to harmonise heritage preservation with cultural industry advancement.
Balancing Practices and Case Studies
This chapter examines practical examples and successful cases of museums navigating the delicate balance between cultural heritage preservation and cultural industry development. By analysing these experiences, the study highlights effective approaches museums use to fulfill their dual missions and maintain equilibrium between conservation and commercialisation.
4.1. Successful Museum Cases: Balancing Preservation and Commercialisation
The Louvre Museum, globally renowned, exemplifies the successful integration of cultural heritage preservation with commercial initiatives. Through meticulously curated exhibitions and engaging displays, the Louvre showcases invaluable artworks while offering visitors a rich exploration of French history and culture [4]. Beyond exhibitions, the museum transforms cultural value into commercial value through merchandise, publications, and digital resources, achieving a coherent balance between preservation and revenue generation. Similarly, the Kyoto National Museum is celebrated for its dedication to preserving and exhibiting Japanese cultural heritage. The museum emphasises authenticity and historical significance in its exhibitions while simultaneously fostering cultural industry engagement. Programs such as cultural experience workshops and art-based educational activities enable visitors to interact with heritage in creative ways, effectively bridging heritage preservation with cultural industry development.
4.2. Innovative Strategies: Digital Technology, Exhibition Design, etc.
Digital technology has become a critical tool in harmonising heritage preservation with commercialisation. Museums utilise virtual exhibitions, mobile applications, and online educational resources to broaden audience reach while providing interactive and informative experiences. Technology also supports efficient artifact management, enhancing preservation efforts without compromising accessibility. Innovative exhibition design further strengthens this balance. By integrating storytelling, multimedia, and interactive elements, museums create immersive visitor experiences that simultaneously educate and entertain. These designs increase audience engagement and generate additional commercial opportunities, contributing to the growth of the cultural industry [5]. Through the examination of exemplary museum cases and the application of innovative strategies, this section illustrates diverse methods for achieving balance. These insights serve as valuable references for museums aiming to reconcile the demands of cultural heritage preservation with the opportunities of cultural industry development.
Conclusion
This paper examined the dual missions of museums in balancing cultural heritage preservation with the development of cultural industries, highlighting strategies for addressing the tensions between conservation and commercialisation. Through the analysis of practical experiences, exemplary museum cases, and innovative strategies, several key conclusions emerge. Firstly, museums occupy a central role in safeguarding and transmitting cultural heritage. By collecting, preserving, and exhibiting artifacts, museums ensure that human history, traditions, and cultural knowledge are passed down to future generations. Secondly, museums actively contribute to the growth of the cultural industry, providing content, experiences, and creative products that stimulate economic activity and cultural innovation.
Successful case studies demonstrate that achieving a balance between preservation and commercialisation is feasible. Institutions such as the Louvre Museum and the Kyoto National Museum illustrate that museums can harmonise these objectives through creative merchandise, immersive experiences, and the effective use of digital technologies, offering models for other institutions to follow. Nonetheless, challenges remain in managing the inherent tension between heritage preservation and commercial imperatives. Overcoming these challenges requires thoughtful policy design, active public engagement, and innovative business models that align cultural stewardship with economic sustainability.
Looking forward, museums will continue to play a vital role in both preserving cultural heritage and fostering cultural industry development. The ongoing evolution of digital technologies and creative exhibition methods presents new opportunities for museums to expand their reach and impact. By embracing collaboration, innovation, and strategic planning, museums can successfully fulfill their dual mission, ensuring that cultural heritage is preserved while cultural industries thrive.
Author Contributions
Isabella M. Laurent: Conceptualisation, research design, methodology, and drafting of the initial manuscript.
Jonathan R. Meyer: Data collection, organisation, validation, and statistical analysis.
Chiara B. Romano: Contextual interpretation, theoretical framing on cultural heritage and museum studies, and critical revision of the manuscript.
Erik L. Schneider: Policy analysis, governance perspectives, and manuscript review.
Sofia K. Alvarez: Literature review, synthesis of findings, and contribution to editing.
All authors read and approved the final version of the manuscript.
Acknowledgments
The authors sincerely acknowledge the valuable participation of educators, policymakers, and school administrators across Europe whose perspectives significantly enriched this research. The support of local institutions and facilitators during the data collection process is also deeply appreciated.
Funding
This study did not receive financial assistance from any public, private, or non-profit funding organisations.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest related to the publication of this paper.
References
[1] Luby, Edward M., Isaya O. Onjala, and Daniel Kibet Arap Mitei. “Museums, Intangible Cultural Heritage,
and Changing Societies: The Ber Gi Dala Exhibition and Cultural Heritage Preservation at the Kisumu
Museum, Kenya.” Museum International 68, no. 3-4 (2016): 118-30.
[2] Kreps, Christina F. Liberating Culture: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Museums, Curation, and Heritage
Preservation. Museum Meanings. London; New York: Routledge, 2003.
[3] Tobiasz, Aleksandra, Jakub Markiewicz, Sławomir Łapiński, Joanna Nikel, Patryk Kot, and Magomed
Muradov. “Review of Methods for Documentation, Management, and Sustainability of Cultural Heritage.
Case Study: Museum of King Jan III’s Palace at Wilanów.” Sustainability (Basel, Switzerland) 11, no. 24
(2019): 7046.
[4] Laforet, Andrea. “Good Intentions and the Public Good.” Ethnologies (Québec) 36, no. 1-2 (2014): 235-
57.
[5] Shaindlin, Valerie Brett. “Reading Museum Exhibits.” The International Journal of Information, Diversity,
& Inclusion 3, no. 2 (2019): 63-79
